Everafter Falls

Everafter Falls

31 ratings
Should I sell or craft?
By lydocia
Putting together some thoughts on whether you should outright sell produce or craft them into items instead.
6
   
Award
Favorite
Favorited
Unfavorite
Introduction
I often find myself thinking, "is this item used as an ingredient, or should I just sell it right away?"

To alleviate my brain capacity a little bit, I thought I'd make a list of things to sell immediately and things to hoard for later crafting.

in general, I'd advise keeping some of every crafting item on hand in case you need them for random quests or jobs.
Crops, fruits and forage
Currently, these items are not used in any recipes:

  • Cauliflower
  • Dragonfruit
  • Eggplant
  • Fairy Fruit
  • Honeydew Melon
  • Rockmelon
  • Sourberry
  • Square Watermelon
  • Turnip

That means their only purpose is selling them right away.

For all other crops, fruits, foraged mushrooms etc., I'd advise using them in cooking recipes as it generally increases their monetary value.

Item
Used in recipes?
Apple
Apple Juice
Avocado
Avocado Butter (used in Golden Egg Toast), Mixed Vegan Sushi Plate, Avocado Pizza
Bluemato
Bluemato Juice, Bluemato Pizza
Blueberry
Blueberry Juice, Fruit Salad, Wurple Pudding
Button Shroom
Wild Shroom Salad, Shroom Pizza
Caramel Fan Shroom
Zorpian Cake
Carrot
Mixed Vegan Sushi Plate
Chili Pepper
Pumpkin Pizza
Corn
Corn Kernels → Popcorn, Corn Sushi Plate
Daikon
Sashimi Plate
Donberry
Donberry Juice, Simple Fruit Salad, Pink Honey Cake
Durian
Durian Pizza
Kobo
Simple Fruit Salad
Kupiberry
Kupiberry Muffin
Lemon
Sashimi Plate
Merryberry
Merryberry Custard
Mulberry
Mulberry Juice, Mulberry Toast
Mushroom Shroom
Wild Shroom Salad
Onion
Onion Potato Pie
Orange
Orange Juice, Fruit Salad
Oyster Shroom
Shroom Pizza
Palm Fruit
Palm Fruit Juice → Palm Sugar
Potato
Fries, Baked Potato, Onion Potato Pie
Pumpkin
Pumpkin Pizza
Rice Stalk
Rice → all kinds of sushi
Soybean
Tofu, Soy Milk
Springfall Shroom
Shroom Stirfry
Star Fruit
Star Fruit Juice
Strawberry
Fruit Salad, Strawberry Waffles, Pink Honey Cake
Tomato
Tomato Pizza, Avocado Pizza
Totonut
Totonut Oil → Vegan Mayonnaise, Wild Shroom Salad
Valley Shroom
Shroom Stirfry
Watermelon
Fruit Salad, Watermelon Swirl
Wheat Stalk
Flour
Winterberry
Winterberry Cake
Wurple
Sweet Wurple Juice, Sour Wurple Juice (used in Wurple Pudding)
Yummyberry
Yummyberry Waffles
Zorpian Fruit
Zorpian Cake
Zulufruit
Zulufruit Custard
Animal produce
Except for the Golden Chicken Egg (which you'll need 3 of for a quest), all produce is processable into other products.

Item
Recipes
Chicken Egg
Mayonnaise, Cheese Omelette, Fried Egg, Egg Toast
Golden Chicken Egg
not in any recipes
Goose Egg
Mayonnaise
Golden Goose Egg
Golden Egg Toast
Whole Cow's Milk
Butter, Cheese (both used in many recipes)
Honeycomb
Honey (used in many recipes)
Pink Honeycomb
Pink Honey (used in Pink Honey Cake)
Giant Pink Honeycomb
Premium Pink Honey
Silk Cocoon
Silk Rope
White Alpaca Wool
White Alpaca Thread
Blue Alpaca Wool
Blue Alpaca Thread

Processing them not only increases their value but these processed items are also used in many other recipes. I'd advise keeping a stock on you for future crafting needs, and selling whichever overflow you may have.
Fish
The only fish used in any cooking recipes are:

Item
Recipes
Bluefin Tuna
Tuna Sushi
Mackerel
Mixed Fish Sushi Plate
Neon Bulbfish
Mixed Fish Sushi Plate
Octopus
Octopus Sushi Plate
Orange Bubblo
Bubblo Sushi
Pinkbelly Grazer
Sashimi Plate
Salmon
Salmon Sushi, Seafood Pizza
Salmon
Salmon Sushi, Seafood Pizza
Sardine
At one point you need 6 for a quest
Squid
Sashimi Plate, Seafood Pizza
White Bubblo
Bubblo Sushi

All other fish are marked to sell immediately, or to end up in your aquarium!
Tree sap (from tapping)
Generally, any tree sap is worth turning into syrup or essence, its value will (more than) double.

Some syrups are used in cooking recipes:

Item
Recipes
Maple Syrup
Strawberry Waffles, Zorpian Cake
Orb Syrup
Orb Syrup Pancakes
Puffle Syrup
Wurple Pudding
Cherry Blossom Syrup
Winterberry Cake


The only exceptions are Pine Resin and Box Resin. Separately worth 40 and 60 gold respectively, but when crafted into Super Glue, worth only 60 gold (thus losing out on 40 gold when crafted for selling). If you don't need Super Glue for any crafting recipes, you're better off selling them separately.
Ores, bars, shards, gems and quartz
Smelting 5 ores into 1 bar (more than) doubles its value, so generally speaking, don't sell ores as they are, stock them up to smelt them.

Selling bars is a quick way to make money, though I'd suggest stocking up on a few of them for later use in recipes such as spheres and orbs.

Selling shards isn't a good idea, you're better off hoarding them and crafting them into spheres and orbs.

Gems are generally just selling fodder, though some recipes use some gems, so you'd better hoard a few of them just to be sure.

Crafting 5 iron ore into a glass panel or crafting 3 quartz into a quartz panel decreases the mateirals' value. Not profitable, so only craft them if you need them for recipes.
Misc. items
Spinning 5 grass into a rope makes no change to the materials' value, so since you'd be losing time, not worth it unless you need rope for a crafting recipe.

6 Comments
lydocia  [author] 22 Aug, 2024 @ 11:05pm 
Yes, that's true, both of those things were deliberately left out of this guide.

It's just for quick-reference, I didn't want to account for all the possible pets and their preferences, or keep it up to date with all the quests. That's for someone else in another guide.
Baddawggy 22 Aug, 2024 @ 5:21pm 
although the produce you listed is not used in any recipes, they may be an animals favorite food. There are also, if I remember correctly, two fish requests that require 6 sardines and I don't remember the other one. maybe someone else can chime in.
lydocia  [author] 2 Jul, 2024 @ 1:05am 
Very welcome, Ella, glad you enjoy it!
ella bee 1 Jul, 2024 @ 11:20pm 
Another essential guide, the crops in particular. Nice to known what I can now sale, without the worry of, I needed that.
lydocia  [author] 1 Jul, 2024 @ 2:12am 
Very welcome, was making it for myself anyway!
OuterGyre 30 Jun, 2024 @ 9:10am 
Thank you for making this. This is exactly the point I am in the game!:steamthumbsup: